[Verse 1]
Evelyn
I hate to wake you up again
It's just that I can't sleep
When any part of me thinks that you got doubt on your mind
Evelyn
I know our love so heaven sent
But it's hard to feel angelic when everything I'm tellin' you feels out of line

[Pre-Chorus]
We used to talk so much now we don't say a thing
Stuck in silence and I'm so tired, you tryna see what all this means

[Chorus]
So tell me what it is
Won't you please, just tell me what it is
'Cause I know that there's a window to your heart that I'm not seein' through
I just gotta find my way in
Won't you tell it to me straight, you know I would appreciate
Often in the way of all the things we wanna say
Know that there's a window to your heart that I'm not seein' through
I just gotta find my way in
Dear Evelyn

[Verse 2]
You always look so innocent
With a brain so academic, why can't I prevent this?
You bringin' me down
I wanna know what point along the way
I started askin' you to put away
All of these feelings, that ain't workin', sealin'
I say it to you
[Pre-Chorus]
We used to walk around, hangin' on by a thread
Stuck in bottom, was hidin' what I knew would set us free

[Chorus]
Won't you tell me what it is
Won't you please, just tell me what it is
I know that there's a window to your heart that I'm not seein' through
Just gotta find my way in
Tell it to me straight, you know I would appreciate
Often in the way of all the things we wanna say
Know that there's a window to your heart that I'm not seein' through
I just gotta find my way in
With you Evelyn

[Outro]
Oh, oh, oh, oh-woah
Oh