[Verse 1]
Hold back the magic
Save your perfume
I sold my mattress
My bedsheets smell like you
I slip in daydreams
Of seeing you naked
Tossin' and turnin'
I'm beggin', but

[Chorus]
Sometimes it feels like the first time
Sometimes it feels like the first time

[Verse 2]
Jane's in the garden
Pullin' up my roots
Guilty and guarded
No matter what I do
So I fill my days with
Unfamiliar faces
Just trying to fill your place, but
Oh, they're not you

[Chorus]
Sometimes it feels like the first time (Ooh)
Sometimes it feels like the first time (Ooh)
Sometimes it feels like the first time (Ooh)
Sometimes you never say goodbye
[Bridge]
Ooh, ooh-ooh
I'm leaving a light on
Ooh, ooh-ooh
I'm leaving a light on

[Chorus]
Sometimes it feels like the first time (I'm leaving a light on)
Sometimes it feels like the first time (Oh, tell me I'm day-drunk)
Sometimes it feels like the first time (I'm leaving a light on)
Sometimes it feels like the first time

[Refrain]
So I fill my days with
Unfamiliar faces
This might be a mistake, but
I'm beggin' you

[Outro]
Ooh
Ooh