[Intro: Aran]
La, la, la, la-la-la
La, la-la-la, la, la-la-la

[Verse 1: Aran, All]
A hopeless romantic all my life
Surrounded by couples all the time
I guess I should take it as a sign
(Oh why, oh why, oh why, oh why?)

[Pre-Chorus: Sio, All]
I'm feelin’ lonely (Lonely)
Oh, I wish I'd find a lover that could hold me (Hold me)
Now I'm crying in my room
So skeptical of love (Say what you say, but I want it more)
But still, I want it more, more, more

[Chorus: FIFTY FIFTY, All]
I gave a second chance to Cupid
But now I’m left here feelin' stupid
Oh, the way he makes me feel that love isn't real
Cupid is so dumb

[Verse 2: Sabrina Carpenter]
(Ah, oh)
I wish that I wasn't so naive (Ah-ah)
And he didn't turn me on so well (Ah-ah)
My heartache's a real good melody, oh
(Oh wow, oh wow, oh wow, oh wow)
And what else is there for me to do?
I gave him one chance, I gave him two
But "third time's the charm" ain't always true
[Chorus: Sabrina Carpenter & All]
I gave a second chance to Cupid
But now I’m left here feelin’ stupid
Oh, the way he makes me feel that love isn't real
Cupid is so dumb

[Post-Chorus: Sabrina Carpenter, All]
Ah, oh
(Cupid is so dumb)

[Bridge: Sabrina Carpenter]
Cupid is a bully, he won’t leave me alone
Every time he set me up, my baby doesn't show
It's makin' me feel crazy like my life’s invisible
Good thing when I cry, I look so cute and beautiful

[Chorus: FIFTY FIFTY, All, (Sabrina Carpenter, Aran, Sio)]
I gave a second chance to Cupid (Cupid, ah)
But now I'm left here feelin' stupid (So stupid, babe, mm)
Oh, the way he makes me feel that love isn't real
Cupid is so dumb
I gave a second chance to Cupid (Hopeless girl is seeking someone)
But now I'm left here feelin' stupid (Who will share this feeling)
Oh, the way he makes me feel that love isn't real (I'm a fool)
Cupid is so dumb (A fool for love, a fool for love)