Mystery girl, I love you
It may seem funny that this could be
But it's true

I've been trying to get next to you
But I can't seem to break the ice
No matter how long it takes
I've gotta get next to you
And I'm ready to pay whatever price

Ooh, girl, if I could at least talk to you
Then I could kinda tell where the problems lie
I'm somewhat overanxious
To find out what it is about you
That's makin' me go outta my mind, baby

Mystery girl, I love you
I love you, yeah
It may seem funny that this could be
But it's true
Mystery girl, can't you see
Can't you see
By you being so mysterious
Ooh, it's hurting me, yeah, yeah

It's a shame how much time I spend
Thinkin' 'bout you night and day
I try to tell myself that I should forget you
But the thought of you just won't go away
I've wanted so much time and energy
Trying to find things that would occupy my mind
Girl, I know this is hopeless
'Cause the problem is you
And you seem to be takin' up all my time, baby

Mystery girl, I love you
Oh, you know that I love you, baby
It may seem funny that this could be
But it's true
Mystery girl, can't you see
By you being so mysterious
Ooh, it's hurting me

Mystery girl, I love you
Yes, I love you, baby
It may seem funny that this could be
But it's true
Oh-whoa, say you're my
Mystery girl, can't you see
Ooh, can't you see
By you being so mysterious
Ooh, it's hurting me
I, I, I, say you're a

Mystery girl, I love you
It may seem funny that this could be
But it's true...