[Verse 1]
I could make you mine
I'm so tempted to touch you
I'm dying to cross the line
But I like your girl too much
I never wanted to meet her
But you let me
So you can't tempt me no more
And you can't have it both ways, baby
So stop making me burn

[Chorus]
I wish I never met your girl
Wish I never met your girl
'Cause I really like her
I wish I never met your girl
Wish I never met your girl
And I don't wanna hurt her
I wish I never met your girl
Your girl, your girl, your girl

[Verse 2]
When she's not by your side
You let our bodies touch
And I'm trying to put out the fire
'Cause I like your girl too much (mmm, yeah)
When she was a stranger
It was so easy
Living in my dream, but now
I can't shoot down an angel
Just because I want to be your midnight queen
No, no
[Chorus]
I wish I never met your girl
Wish I never met your girl
'Cause I really like her
I wish I never met your girl
Wish I never met your girl
And I don't wanna hurt her
I wish I never met your girl
Your girl, your girl, your girl

[Bridge]
Close my eyes every night
Try to dream about you
But I only see her face
Though my heart wants you now
I can live without you
Never talk about you
Never, ever have to say

[Chorus]
I wish I never met your girl
Wish I never met your girl
'Cause I really like her
And I wish I didn't like your girl
Wish I didn't like your girl–
But I do
And I don't wanna hurt her
I wish I never met your girl
Your girl, your girl, your girl
I wish I never met your girl
Your girl, your girl, your girl